Exploring the System Hardware Attack Surface: Rings and Rootkits

Introduction

The system hardware attack surface includes multiple layers of a computer system below the operating system (OS) that can be exploited by attackers. These layers, such as the hypervisor, firmware, and chipset, provide critical functionality but also present vulnerabilities. In this article, we’ll explore the attack surface at these layers, define the concept of security rings (0 to -3), and understand how rootkits exploit these layers to gain unauthorized control.

---

Understanding the System Hardware Layers

Traditionally, computer systems are viewed in four primary layers:

1. User Layer: Where end-users interact with applications.
2. Application Layer: Software programs running on the OS.
3. OS Layer: Manages hardware and software resources.
4. Hardware Layer: The physical components of the computer.

However, modern systems include additional layers beneath the OS, such as:

• Hypervisor: Allocates hardware resources for virtual machines.
• Firmware and Operating Modes: Includes BIOS, UEFI, and System Management Mode (SMM).
• Chipset: Handles low-level hardware tasks and can operate independently of firmware and the OS.

---

Rings of Privilege and Rootkits

Security rings are conceptual layers of privilege in a computer system. Traditionally, the x86 architecture defines four rings:

• Ring 3: User applications.
• Ring 0: OS kernel.

Recent advancements and attacks have introduced “negative rings” to describe privilege layers below the OS:

• Ring -1: Hypervisor.
• Ring -2: Firmware (BIOS/UEFI) and SMM.
• Ring -3: Chipset-level operations.

Types of Rootkits and Their Attack Layers

1. Ring 0 Rootkits (OS Rootkits):
   Exploit OS kernel privileges to hide from user-level detection tools.
2. Ring -1 Rootkits (Hypervisor Rootkits):
   • Compromise the hypervisor, which manages virtual machines.
   • Example: Blue Pill Attack – A VM-based rootkit that hides malicious activities by operating at the hypervisor level.
3. Ring -2 Rootkits (Firmware and SMM Rootkits):
   • Attack the BIOS, UEFI, or System Management Mode (SMM).
   • Suspend normal execution to execute malicious firmware code.
4. Ring -3 Rootkits (Chipset Rootkits):
   • Subvert chipset functionality, such as Intel Active Management Technology (AMT), to install backdoors.
   • Example: Intel Q35 Attack – Exploits chipset capabilities to execute code independently of the main CPU.

---

Key Components of the Hardware Attack Surface

Hypervisor (Ring -1)

A hypervisor is software or firmware that creates and manages virtual machines (VMs). It can:

• Allocate resources to multiple OSs running on the same hardware.
• Exist as a Type 1 Hypervisor (runs directly on hardware) or Type 2 Hypervisor (runs within a host OS).

Attack Surface:
A compromised hypervisor allows attackers to manipulate all VMs running on it, including their OS and applications.

Firmware and System Management Mode (Ring -2)

Firmware, including BIOS and UEFI, initializes hardware and controls low-level system operations. System Management Mode (SMM) provides high-privilege access to handle tasks like power management and error handling.

Attack Surface:

• Malicious firmware updates or SMM exploitation can bypass OS-level protections.
• Firmware-level attacks persist even after reinstalling the OS.

Chipset (Ring -3)

The chipset operates independently of the main CPU and is responsible for low-level hardware functions. It can execute instructions autonomously, making it an attractive target for attackers.

Attack Surface:
Compromising the chipset gives attackers unparalleled control over the hardware and firmware.

---

Consequences of Compromising Lower Rings

The lower the compromised ring, the greater the control attackers have over the system. For example:

• Hypervisor Compromise (Ring -1): All OSs and applications running on the hypervisor are vulnerable.
• SMM Compromise (Ring -2): Attackers can manipulate firmware and control the hypervisor.
• Chipset Compromise (Ring -3): Complete system control, including firmware, hypervisor, and OS.

---

Mitigation Strategies

Securing the hardware attack surface requires layered defenses to protect each privilege ring.

1. Secure Boot:
   Ensure only trusted firmware and OS components are loaded during startup.
2. Firmware Protections:
   • Enable BIOS/UEFI write protections.
   • Use authenticated firmware updates with cryptographic signatures.
3. Hardware-Based Security Features:
   • Trusted Platform Modules (TPMs) to validate firmware integrity.
   • Intel Boot Guard to ensure only verified firmware is executed.
4. Hypervisor Hardening:
   • Use Type 1 hypervisors for critical applications.
   • Monitor hypervisor logs for unusual activities.
5. Chipset Security:
   • Regularly update chipset firmware to patch vulnerabilities.
   • Restrict physical access to systems to prevent low-level attacks.

---

Conclusion

The system hardware attack surface is vast, spanning multiple layers below the OS. From hypervisors and firmware to chipsets, each layer introduces unique vulnerabilities that attackers can exploit. By understanding the security rings and implementing robust protections, organizations can defend against even the most sophisticated rootkit attacks.