Cyber war is a term that has been debated and defined in various ways over the years. At its core, it involves the use of computers, networks, and other digital technologies to conduct activities that may have traditionally been considered acts of war, such as attacks on infrastructure or espionage. However, the concept is more complex and multifaceted than it might first appear.
Defining Cyber War
The traditional definition of war, as given by the Prussian General Carl von Clausewitz, describes it as violent, instrumental, and political. When applying this to the digital realm, one might initially think of cyber war as using computers to conduct violent attacks with political objectives. However, this simplistic view does not entirely align with the realities of modern cyber operations.
Cyber Warfare vs. Cyber War
A more accurate term, as suggested by experts like Dr. Thomas Rid, might be “cyber warfare” rather than “cyber war.” Cyber warfare encompasses a broader range of activities that do not always involve direct violence but can still have significant political and strategic impacts. These activities include:
- Subversion: Undermining the integrity of political or social systems. For example, disinformation campaigns or hacking into electoral systems.
- Espionage: Stealing confidential information, such as state secrets or corporate data. Notable examples include the alleged Chinese cyber theft of fighter jet plans or the targeting of COVID-19 vaccine manufacturers.
- Sabotage: Disrupting the availability of critical infrastructure or services. The NotPetya attack on Ukraine, which targeted power distribution plants, is a classic example of cyber sabotage.
Real-World Examples and Implications
The ongoing conflict between Ukraine and Russia provides a contemporary context for understanding cyber warfare. Since 2014, Ukraine has faced numerous cyberattacks, including the NotPetya malware attack and the disruption of its power grid. These incidents, though not conventional acts of war, have had significant impacts on the country’s infrastructure and population.
Another pertinent example is the series of cyber operations between Israel and Iran. These include Israel’s cyberattacks on Iranian nuclear facilities and ports, and Iran’s retaliatory attacks on Israeli infrastructure. These operations are often carried out with a high degree of anonymity, complicating the issue of attribution—a key challenge in defining and responding to cyber warfare.
Conclusion: The Evolving Landscape of Cyber Warfare
Cyber war, as traditionally understood, may not have occurred yet, and some experts argue that it may never happen in the conventional sense. However, cyber warfare is an increasingly important aspect of modern conflicts, where digital tools are used to subvert, spy, and sabotage without the direct use of force. Understanding this nuanced landscape is crucial as nation-states and other actors continue to develop and deploy cyber capabilities as part of their broader military and strategic arsenals.
We love to share our knowledge on current technologies. Our motto is ‘Do our best so that we can’t blame ourselves for anything“.